business man in office

How Construction Disputes Really Form?

Between Engineering Reality and Contractual Assumption

Mark Lincoln | Managing Director, SJA

 

My interest in construction began long before I understood contracts or disputes.

As a child travelling through Norway, I was struck by the way infrastructure was integrated into extreme terrain. Roads and tunnels carved through mountains and alongside fjords were not presented as exceptional achievements – they were simply part of how the environment was made accessible. That experience left a lasting impression:

 

“that construction is ultimately about translating ambition into physical reality under constraint.”

 

It was this perspective that led me into civil engineering and subsequently into the direct planning, management and co-ordination of the delivery of construction projects.

At that stage, my focus was firmly on execution – how projects are built, sequenced and delivered. Over time, however, that perspective evolved. It became clear that the most significant divergences in construction do not emerge during execution itself, but much earlier in how projects are framed, scoped and contractually configured.

 


 

In practice, most construction disputes do not begin with disagreement.

They begin with divergence from an assumed baseline that was never fully aligned between the parties.

That baseline typically includes:

  • the scope as understood at contract formation
  • the programme as planned at commencement
  • the methodology assumed for delivery
  • and the allocation of risk embedded in the contract

 

What is often underestimated is how quickly these elements begin to drift once a project is underway, not necessarily through failure, but through the cumulative effect of minor adjustments, sequencing changes and evolving site conditions.

By the time a formal dispute emerges, the project being analysed is often materially different from the one originally assumed by either party.

Understanding that divergence is central to effective expert analysis.

 


 

From delivery to contractual reality

My career has spanned a wide range of construction and engineering environments, each contributing to an understanding of how that divergence occurs in practice.

I initially commenced my career as a site engineer on the O-Bahn busway in Adelaide, a major civil infrastructure project. From there, I moved into commercial and retail construction, working on high-rise developments in both site engineering and planning roles.

Over time, my roles expanded across oil and gas, mining infrastructure, civil engineering portfolios, hotel construction, defence logistics and telecommunications delivery. These positions included project management, contract management and commercial leadership roles across multi-disciplinary environments.

I also worked in consulting with PricewaterhouseCoopers, advising on quantum and risk across major infrastructure sectors including airports, health infrastructure, housing, mining and other social infrastructure developments.

What this breadth of experience revealed in practice is that disputes rarely arise from a single event. They are usually the product of a sequence of decisions, each reasonable in isolation, but collectively leading to a position that differs from the contractual assumption.

 

How I approach dispute reconstruction

In expert work, the task is not to restate the contract, nor to describe the outcome. It is to reconstruct how the project moved from an agreed baseline to a disputed position.

 

That reconstruction begins with three core pillars:

  • the contractual allocation of risk
  • the defined matters in dispute
  • the legal case theory being advanced

 

These establish the boundaries of analysis, but they do not explain the totality of issues, particularly in respect of matters of quantum and reasonableness of decision making.

The more important analytical step is reconstructing the baseline reality of the project, including scope, programme and intended methodology.

From there, the focus shifts to understanding how and when divergence occurred and to then conclude as to the impact of that divergence on the whole of the project.

 

In practical terms, that analysis typically involves working through:

  • what the baseline scope, programme and methodology actually were
  • whether the assumptions underpinning them were reasonable at the time
  • how changes in scope or conditions evolved over time
  • what those changes meant in practical delivery terms
  • who bears responsibility under the contractual framework
  • whether concurrent events influenced performance
  • and how those factors translate into measurable impact

 

This is not a checklist exercise. It is a process of reconstructing and analysing the project fact set in a way that is consistent with risk allocation between the parties and relevant “rules” included in the contract, particularly in relation to matters of valuation.

 

The evidential reality behind disputes

A key challenge in expert work is that contemporaneous records often reflect administration, not causation.

Programme updates, correspondence and progress reporting provide important context, but they do not always explain why outcomes occurred. The role of the expert is to bridge that gap – linking recorded events to actual project behaviour and contractual consequence.

This is where the concept of an evidential nexus becomes critical: ensuring that there is a clear and continuous connection between the issue in dispute, the contractual framework and the quantifiable impact.

Without that linkage, analysis risks describing what happened without explaining why it happened in contractual terms.

 

Communicating technical reality in legal forums

Expert evidence must ultimately function in a legal environment.

That means complex engineering and commercial issues must be expressed in a way that is accessible to decision-makers without distorting technical meaning.

 

My approach is therefore focused on:

  • clarity of assumptions
  • transparency of methodology
  • logical sequencing of reasoning
  • and direct alignment between evidence and conclusion

 

The objective is not simplification. It is intelligibility under scrutiny.

 


 

Construction disputes sit at the intersection of engineering execution and contractual expectation.

In my experience, the most significant insight in dispute analysis is that divergence is rarely sudden. It is gradual, cumulative and often only visible retrospectively once the project is reconstructed against its original baseline.

The role of the expert witness is to make that reconstruction explicit, structured and evidence-based so that tribunals can understand not only what changed, but how and why those changes translated into the disputed outcome.

That is the discipline I apply in every instruction: translating engineering reality into contractual clarity, grounded in evidence and expressed with precision.

 

On a final note, I am still a regular visitor to Norway and still marvel at the engineering infrastructure use to access and tame that wonderful wilderness.  This year sees me in northern Norway visiting Tromso, Vengsoy, Alta, Honnningsvag, Nordkapp and Kirkenes.

 

 

 

 

 

About the Author

 

Mark Lincoln

Managing Director, SJA | Expert Witness – Construction, Engineering & Infrastructure Disputes

Mark Lincoln is a construction and engineering expert witness with extensive experience across major infrastructure, civil engineering, building and energy sectors. His career spans project delivery, commercial leadership, contract management and quantum and delay advisory roles across Australia and international markets.

He commenced his career in civil engineering on the O-Bahn busway project in Adelaide and has since held senior roles across commercial construction, oil and gas, mining infrastructure, defence logistics, telecommunications and multi-disciplinary engineering portfolios.

Prior to joining SJA in 2017, Mark provided quantum and risk advisory services with PricewaterhouseCoopers across a broad range of infrastructure sectors including airports, health infrastructure, housing, mining and social infrastructure.

As an expert witness, Mark specialises in the structured analysis of construction disputes, including delay, disruption, quantum and process. His approach focuses on reconstructing project delivery against contractual baselines, with particular emphasis on scope definition, programme analysis and evidential linkage between events and outcome.

 

Share this post