For more than two decades, I have worked across construction projects in the UK, the Middle East and Australia. During this time, I have held many roles including project manager, superintendent, employers agent and principal’s representative. Through this, I have seen the Superintendent role from every angle, the good, the bad and the deeply conflicted.
Two years ago, I completed a Master of Construction Law thesis on a topic that had intrigued me for most of my career: “the Superintendent’s obligation to act impartially”. I wanted to understand why this role, which should be a stabilising force in a project, so often becomes a flashpoint for tension, mistrust and disputes.
My research confirmed what I had long suspected: the industry does not understand the Superintendent’s impartiality obligations and the consequences are significant.
What’s more concerning is this: two years later, nothing seems to have changed.
In fact, the same issues I documented in my research are still happening on projects today, sometimes more blatantly than ever.
This article is not an academic paper. It’s a reflection on what I found, what I’ve become aware of since and why the construction industry needs to rethink how we approach the Superintendent’s role.
The Dual Role: A Conflict We Pretend Isn’t There
The Superintendent is expected to do two things that fundamentally contradict each other:
- Firstly, act as the Principal’s representative, protecting their interests and issuing directions on their behalf.
- Secondly, act impartially, particularly when assessing claims, certifying payments and determining extensions of time.
This is often referred to as the Superintendent wearing two hats. Anyone who has worked on a live project knows how challenging this can be.
You cannot be paid by one party, report to one party, be influenced by one party and then be expected to make decisions that may go against that same party without pressure, without consequence and without bias.
This tension is not new. It has been recognised for more than a century. As far back as Hickman v Roberts (1913) the court held that the contract administrator (such as an architect or superintendent) must carry out their certification functions impartially. Decades later, in Perini v Commonwealth (1969) the court went further, implying a term into the contract requiring the superintendent to act impartially, even though the superintendent was an employee of the client.
More recently, in V601 Developments v Probuild (2021) the superintendent was found to have collaborated with the client when assessing claims. The court held that the superintendent failed to act independently, reinforcing that impartiality is not optional: it is a legal requirement.
These cases span more than 100 years, yet the same behaviour continues today.
What My Research Revealed And Why It Still Matters
As part of my study, I surveyed a broad cross‑section of the construction industry in Sydney Australia, including those working for client organisations, contractors and consultants. These were not junior staff or people unfamiliar with the Superintendent role. 91% had more than 10 years’ experience in the industry.
Here’s what they told me:
- Most believe Superintendents do not act impartially.
More than half of all respondents said they do not see impartiality in practice. Among contractors, that number jumped to 77%.
This isn’t a perception issue. It’s a reality issue.
- Client influence is the biggest barrier.
Respondents overwhelmingly identified client influence as the primary reason Superintendents struggle to remain impartial.
This influence isn’t always explicit. Sometimes it’s subtle; a raised eyebrow, a budget reminder, a “we need to be careful here” comment. But the effect is the same.
- Contract amendments are making the problem worse.
Many standard form contracts are amended to:
- weaken impartiality obligations
- remove them entirely
- reinforce the Superintendent’s role as the Principal’s Agent
This is not accidental. It’s deliberate.
- The industry lacks clarity and education
Respondents highlighted that:
- impartiality obligations are poorly defined in standard form contracts
- terminology varies between forms of contract
- many practitioners are insufficiently trained in the impartiality obligations of the Superintendent
This lack of clarity creates inconsistent behaviour and inconsistent behaviour creates disputes.
What I’ve Become Aware of Since Finishing the Research
Since publishing my research, many people across the industry have shared their own experiences with me and the themes are alarmingly consistent.
I’ve been told about:
- Superintendents feeling pressured to reject or limit claims
- Impartiality clauses being removed without explanation
- Certification decisions being reviewed or “aligned” before issue
- Contractors choosing not to submit claims because they believed the outcome was predetermined
- Disputes escalating because the Superintendent was viewed as an extension of the client’s commercial team rather than an independent decision‑maker
These stories come from different voices, but they paint the same picture. The impartiality problem is not theoretical: it is a lived reality for many practitioners.
Why This Matters More Than Ever
The construction industry is under enormous pressure:
- rising costs
- tight margins
- labour shortages
- complex delivery models
- increasing regulatory scrutiny
In this environment, the Superintendent should be a stabilising force and a fair arbiter who keeps the project moving and prevents disputes.
Instead, the role is often a catalyst for conflict.
When impartiality breaks down:
- claims escalate
- relationships deteriorate
- delays increase
- legal costs rise
- projects become adversarial
Industry data suggests disputes consume a measurable percentage of project value each year. When applied across Australia’s construction pipeline, the cost to the industry is significant.
We cannot afford to keep getting this wrong.
What Needs to Change: A Personal View
My thesis concluded with several recommendations. Two years later, I believe in them even more strongly.
1. We need clearer contracts
Contracts should explicitly state what impartiality means and when it applies. Ambiguous language helps no one.
2. We need fewer amendments that undermine impartiality
If the Superintendent is expected to be impartial, the contract must support that expectation: not contradict it.
3. We need better education
Superintendents, contractors, consultants and especially clients need to understand:
- what impartiality requires
- why it matters
- how to manage conflicts of interest
- how impartiality reduces disputes
4. We need to rethink how Superintendents are engaged.
One model worth exploring is separating the Superintendent’s representative and certifier functions or jointly engaging an independent assessor for certification duties.
This would reduce perceived bias and strengthen trust.
5. We need cultural change.
This is the hardest part.
Clients need to understand that impartiality is not a threat to their interests. It is a safeguard.
A fair process protects everyone.
A Final Thought
When I began my thesis, I thought the problem was primarily contractual. By the time I finished, I realised it was cultural.
And now, two years later, after witnessing the same issues unfold, I’m convinced of one thing:
The Superintendent’s impartiality problem will not fix itself.
It will only change when the industry decides it matters.
- When clients stop seeing impartiality as a loss of control.
- When Superintendents are empowered to act independently.
- When contractors trust the process enough to engage with it.
- When contracts reflect the reality of the role, not the idealised version of it.
The solutions are not complicated. The challenge is the willingness to adopt them.
Until then, the Superintendent will remain one of the most misunderstood and most conflicted roles in construction.
And the industry will continue paying the price.
About the Author
Ben Marshall | SJA – Regional Manager (Expert and Project Management Services) NSW/ACT
Ben Marshall specialises in expert advisory and project management services. He is a senior project management professional with over 23 years’ international experience across the UK, Middle East and Australia, having worked as a project manager and superintendent across a wide range of sectors. He has led and delivered major residential, commercial, health, education and mixed-use developments, bringing a practical, whole-of-lifecycle perspective to project delivery and contract administration.
Ben holds a degree in Construction Project Management as well as a Master of Construction Law and Practice. He has extensive expertise in Project Management and Superintendency under JCT, AS, FIDIC and GC21 forms of contract. He has also prepared expert witness reports and regularly advises on complex project and dispute-related matters.
+61 2 9236 5000

